Carlsberg Britvic's Dr Caroline Withers explains why the next generation of drinks innovation is about more than what a product tastes like.
In a crowded soft drinks market, finding the next successful flavour combination is becoming increasingly challenging.
But according to Dr Caroline Withers, Consumer and Sensory Science Director at Carlsberg Britvic, brands should be thinking beyond flavour alone.
Speaking to Emma Eversham during BeverageDaily's Beverage Innovation 2026 webinar on 17 November, Caroline discussed how appearance, aroma, texture and even the way a drink is consumed can influence its success.
Her central argument was that successful innovation comes from considering the entire drinking experience.
Familiarity with a twist
One of the biggest challenges for drinks brands is balancing familiarity with novelty.
Consumers need to recognise something about a product before they're willing to try it. But if an innovation feels too familiar, there may be little reason to choose it over an existing favourite.
Caroline highlighted Pepsi's salted caramel innovation as an example.
Cola already contains complex flavour characteristics, including caramel and spices. Introducing salted caramel builds on something consumers recognise while offering a new experience.
It's an approach that allows brands to innovate without losing the qualities that made their products successful in the first place.
Innovation isn't always about what's inside the bottle
Carlsberg Britvic's current innovation pipeline demonstrates how brands can experiment with different sensory experiences.
Tango Sours combines familiar fruit flavours with a more challenging sour sensation.
Plenish has explored additional complexity in plant-based drinks, including chocolate and sea salt combinations.
But perhaps the most unusual example is Turbo Tango.
The brand has reintroduced an aerosolised format that delivers Tango as a foam directly into the mouth.
It's an example of innovation changing not just the flavour, but the way consumers interact with the product.
For established drinks brands, this raises an interesting question: could changing the drinking experience create more excitement than launching another flavour extension?
Why colour matters before the first sip
Visual cues play a significant role in shaping expectations.
Packaging colours can communicate intensity, refreshment, naturalness or indulgence before a consumer has even opened a product.
Caroline pointed to J2O Apple Shimmer, which combines spiced apple flavours with a shimmering appearance.
The visual effect helps communicate that this is something more complex than a conventional apple drink, creating a sense of occasion before consumption.
This matters because expectations influence the overall product experience.
When appearance, aroma, texture and flavour work together, the result can feel more distinctive and memorable.
The importance of understanding the occasion
Caroline also emphasised the importance of understanding where, when and why consumers drink.
A beverage consumed on the way to work serves a different purpose from one enjoyed with friends or as an evening treat.
Successful innovation needs to reflect those differences.
It's not enough to create an interesting formulation in a laboratory. Brands need to understand the expectations and behaviours surrounding the moment of consumption.
That means involving consumers throughout the development process, rather than simply testing whether they like a finished product.
What can drinks brands learn?
For brands operating in saturated categories, differentiation doesn't necessarily require discovering an entirely new ingredient or flavour.
It might come from texture, presentation, aroma, packaging or a different way of consuming the product.
The strongest innovations combine something recognisable with something unexpected.
The opportunity is to move beyond asking what a drink should taste like and start asking what the whole experience should feel like.
Got a drink people need to experience to understand?
Great flavour, unusual textures and innovative formats can be difficult to communicate through packaging alone. Sometimes, the best way to build demand is to get your product into the right hands.
Introducing Stir's Product Trial Sprint.
A targeted campaign designed to get your drink in front of relevant influencers and tastemakers, generating first-hand experiences, content and conversations around what makes it different.
From audience identification and creative concept development to targeted sampling and influencer outreach, we'll help turn product curiosity into trial.
Looking to get more people trying your drink? Get in touch to find out more about our Product Trial Sprint.
This article draws on insights shared during BeverageDaily's Beverage Innovation 2026 webinar, hosted by Emma Eversham on 17 November 2026.
